Here is my official recommendation - order the garlic fries from . Here is my further suggestion - have them delivered.
The first time I ordered the garlic fries from Chicago Pizza & Catering, I put them in my car and drove them home. Then, for about a week, I was safe from vampires as the remaining garlic smell would surely have driven them away.
The garlic fries at CP & P are good. They are not my favorite - those are found a little drive away in Lemont at . In an effort to make them more like Lemon Tree, I threw them in a pan with butter. It was better, but nothing can top Lemon Tree.
If you are not a fan of garlic fries, I am told the pizza is a great choice and a really good pizza. For towns that are used to take-out pizza that is fairly cookie cutter, my family tells me that the pizza from CP & P has real flavor. The crust was cheesy and the sauce was good. Finding a pizza made with intention is a great thing. I cannot eat regular pizza. My favorite in the area is found at Fat Boyz.
In addition to the pizza and garlic fries, I ordered the Chee-Z-Beef. Next to its listing on the menu, CP & P says it is highly recommended. It was ok. Although I admit that I could not give it a fair shake since I ate the inside out of the bun with a fork.
All in all, I recommend you try Angie's Chicago Pizza & Catering. Their full menu is available online.